Interesting columns this morning by both Lorrie Goldstein and Chantel Hebert – and both having to do with the ongoing Liberal misfortunes. Many pundits have acknowledged that the Grits do indeed have a problem and several have offered observations and advice, whether solicited or not.
When I first read the headline of Lorrie’s column I thought he had gone over to the dark side – Why Tories should think kindly of Frank Graves … a little. However he makes some excellent points. There within Frank Graves’ now infamous advice for the Liberals is an admission that the Conservatives are ‘winning the culture war’, according to Goldstein’s interpretation of Lawrence Martin’s paraphrasing of the interview (whew!):
“In contrast to the Liberals, Stephen Harper has been able to define what his party is all about. The Conservative base, says Mr. Graves, is remarkably unified and committed. ‘It isn’t fiscal conservatism which sustains this true-believer status. It is a sense of moral mission and rightness.’ Canadian progressives, on the other hand, are scattered and demoralized, their torpor a product of having no sense of ringing purpose.”
If we concentrate solely on that paragraph, I suppose it could indeed be taken as a compliment but the Liberals would be quick to attack nasty religious or moral overtones to it. And we can’t have any of that in Trudeaupia.
But I think there may be a grain of truth in Goldstein’s interpretation in that Liberals do seem to want to be in power at any cost, whereas Conservatives are more driven by values, principles and a non-Nanny State ideology. I realize is a very overly-simplistic view but perhaps it deserves some thought.
It does seem to be true that the Liberal sense of entitlement includes being in power and that ‘right’ has been denied them ever since the reunited Conservative Party defeated Paul Martin in 2006. The Liberals have been desperate to get back to 24 Sussex and almost made it there during the Coalition crisis of December 2008, with the help of the NDP and the Bloc.
Chantel Hebert picks up this theme in her column which has various headlines depending which Torstar site you visit. The Record has labeled it A year into the job, Ignatieff’s Liberals are lost. She lists various blunders by Mr. Ziffy and his sorry band of advisers, including his latest gaffe on Sunday when he deliberately politicized the Governor General’s appointment for partisan gain. Hebert points out:
Many found Ignatieff’s apparent willingness to turn the selection of the next governor-general into a partisan exercise unseemly.
It does not help that at the time when he was in opposition, Harper resisted the same temptation. When rumours that Jean was sovereigntist sympathizer surfaced mere days after her appointment, Harper turned down calls from within his own inner circle to press for the nomination to be rescinded.
BTW, major kudos go to the Conservative war room for resisting the temptation to take potshots at Ignatieff’s lack of good judgment there. Don’t mess it up guys!
But back to Hebert. She either suggests or advises that the Liberals’ only chance to get back into power may be to rekindle the Coalition in spite of Mr. Ziffy’s assurances that he would not do so:
Ignatieff spent his first year as leader telling all comers that he would not entertain power-sharing deals with the NDP.
Yet, based on current polls, a governing arrangement with the New-Democrats offers the Liberals their best (and possibly only) hope of coming back to government after the next election.
A year after Ignatieff’s coronation,the party is more than ever without a roadmap.
So will that final lifeline that saves the Ziffy Liberals be sent by their opposition partners?
Or will they try to actually put together a plan to save themselves from drifting any further from the Canadian centre and from a rudderless journey that’s going nowhere?
* * * *
Update
Mr. Ziffy steps in it again – Sammy catches the action.
* * * *
Friday Update
More talk of coalitions from discontented Liberal MSM – Liberals are spinning their policy wheels.
* * * *
Saturday Update
Even more coalition talk – Familiar drama across pond – CH
* * * *
Tuesday Update
Ex-minister has some advice for the Liberals - Barbara Yaffe, Vancouver Sun