I like my headline better than the Globe’s.
In any case, kudos to Jim Flaherty and Finance Ministers of the other G20 countries (eg. Japan, Australia) that held strong to the notion of not punishing good performance and competent management:
…The decision to make the bank tax voluntary for G20 members is essentially what Canada, through Mr. Flaherty and Prime Minister Stephen Harper, have argued in recent weeks as the two men blitzed key the world for face-to-face meetings with key G20 members including the E.U., China and India...
This whole controversy was a “distraction from core issues” as Flaherty noted. Now they can get on with more important business:
…In their communique, the ministers called for strong measures to improve the transparency, regulation and supervision of hedge funds, credit rating agencies, compensation practices and OTC (over the counter) derivatives…
Is it possible that even TD might have some positive commentary regarding the current Canadian Government now? That would be such a novelty.
And how about you Mr. Ziffy? And reaction?
Or are you preoccupied with visions of the Ghost of Liberal Victories Past?
* * * *
Update
On the Bank Tax, Its Canada 1 – Europe 0 – ChuckerCanuk
* * * *
Sunday Update
Bank tax doesn’t get to the root of problem – Angelo Persichilli, Star:
…the proposed tax addresses the consequences of potential mismanagement or abuse by financial institutions of the sort that they committed two years ago, but it doesn’t address the cause.
The real problem is the lack of rules that allows banks to operate the most vital public service in a very private and monopolistic way.…
…New technologies have unleashed the creativity of many greedy and unscrupulous people who have transformed the stock market into the world’s biggest unlegislated gambling operation at the expense of millions of genuine and small investors.
With the push of a button, these high-tech gamblers are able to make money in Canada if a plane crashes in Poland, generate profits in New York if there is a bomb in Nigeria, or make us pay more for our gas if there is an earthquake in Indonesia. That’s not the traditional rule of supply and demand — it’s cheating by creating a reduction of supply that doesn’t exist and, by default, an increase in demand that never materializes.
Talking about implementing a tax on banks to fix the problems we have now is like selling umbrellas to fight tsunamis...
Exactly. In fact I think it would have exasperated the problem by providing a ‘get out of jail free’ card to offending institutions.
How we all got screwed – Lorrie Goldstein, Sun:
...here’s a scaled-down version of Lewis’ marvellous book.
Basically, a bunch of uber-greedy U.S. investment banks packaged crappy mortgage loans into crappy mortgage bonds, then repackaged the crappiest of those into even crappier bonds, and then sold the whole sorry mess to institutional investors around the world.
This with the blessing of the major U.S. bond rating agencies, who didn’t know or didn’t care the stuff was crap.
Not only was it crap, it was leveraged crap — meaning it was largely financed with debt — making the eventual losses exponentially worse.
Finally, these money houses shorted the crap they were selling — basically taking out bets it would turn to crap, even as they were telling investors it was gold.
These mortgage bonds were crap because they were underpinned by “subprime” mortgage loans given to people who didn’t have a hope in hell of ever paying them back, once their delayed interest payments started to kick in after the first few years…
The Canadian media on Stephen Harper and the global bank tax – Stephen Taylor (H/T Sammy)